Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Physical Environments Part 2

We had discussed in class how this issue could go either way, I believe that Lindsay would appreciate having the Office of Disability, either in the student center, or at least in a central part of campus.  Having this proximity sends her the nonverbal message that she is valued, that the office is readily available to her in a central location so that she can easily access her resources or address any issues.  Having the office in a central location also lessens any stigmas and serves as an artifact of the institution’s commitment to helping students with disabilities to succeed.
In line with satisfaction and retention, Lindsay would need to be able to feel involved with other students and faculty.  It would be important for buildings, such as the student center or residence halls, to have less crowded areas to study or interact with others.  Being more visually aware than hearing students, constant hustle and bustle of people moving around her as she’s trying to engage with others or her studies may be too distracting.  Also, since Lindsay, being raised by a hearing family, has learned to lip read as well as sign, when communicating with hearing individuals, it is essential that she can find soft architecture, allowing furniture to be maneuvered to face each other, allowing her to participate fully in her conversations.  These quieter areas with soft architecture provide her sociopital, functional, and flexible space to further her involvement with others.
This of course, is all hypothetical and “ideal”.  I need to look into what is truly available at Ohio State and Bowling Green.  I know that in the student center of Ohio State, there is definitely plenty of quieter areas with soft architecture.  Having never experienced any alarms in the Ohio Union, I’m unsure if they would provide that safety mechanism for her there.  I will need to do more in depth research on what other buildings, residence halls, and campus layout have to offer.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Let's Get Physical

After all of our classes, I find that physical environment is one that I find easiest to observe, and focus on.  I’ve also found it difficult to reflect on some of these concepts before understanding more about the deaf experience, which is so expansive; it’s really taking me awhile.  In the past couple of weeks, I’ve started thinking about things that Lindsay might need in a physical environment.  Since Lindsay has a very weak sense of hearing, her sight and other senses are heightened.  Something that Lindsay would be looking for, and is likely pretty dependent on, is lots of visual aids, especially signs and maps of buildings and campus.  Way-finding can be difficult enough in a new environment, but by not being able to communicate readily with other students and faculty in order to ask for directions, it would be essential to Lindsay that she is able to find where she needs to go in a self-sufficient manner.  (Regardless, even hearing students would greatly benefit from well-placed signs helping them find their way around.)
In order for Lindsay to feel satisfied on a campus, it is crucial that she feels included and safe in her environment.  In terms of safety, any safety devices (such as tornado warnings and fire alarms), should be accompanied by visual alerts, such as flashing lights, so that she can be aware of the warnings as well as be prepared for what will likely be the rush and commotion of people that she might not otherwise be prepared for.  It makes me think about the systems that we have in the residence halls here.  We are very dependent on using our public announcement system to get last minute advertisement and information to residents.  Unless we have plenty of signs up ahead of time, Lindsay could completely miss really important information.  We try to avoid this by putting up lots of posters in advance, however this is not always possible.  Luckily, for fire and tornado alarms, we offer bed shakers that vibrate the bed violently when the alarm goes off.  According to Disability Service’s Emergency Evacuation pamphlet, “Most buildings on campus are not yet equipped with visual alarms. Some persons with hearing impairments may not perceive audio emergency alarms and will need to be alerted to the situation by gestures or by turning the light switch off and on. Emergency instructions can be given by verbalizing, mouthing, or by a short, explicit note. Example: ‘Fire alarm -- go out south doors—now!’  It is appropriate to offer assistance to a hearing impaired person as you leave the building.”  It is interesting that they readily accept that there are no visual alarms  in most of our buildings, but it is not well advertised that others are supposed to assist these hard of hearing students in that situation.

Sunday, February 20, 2011

Studying...

The last article I read mentioned that study habits and cognitive level and interpretation of material likely played a part in how DHH students learn and succeed academically, so I thought it’d be a good idea to research any differences in studying.  This study found that differences in studying were very slight and that DHH students were just as capable of making meaning of the material learned.  The inventory identified eight scales for studying, and found that DHH students were statistically significant on four of the eight scales.  The study also found (and it was briefly mentioned in the last article as well) that DHH students have a more difficult time making connections between different topics, which was more pronounced in students who explicitly used sign.  However, DHH students are more likely to critically analyze topics taught.
Previous literature focused on how there were different levels of learning, e.g. “surface level”, which is similar to regurgitation.  This is similar to what was mentioned in the previous article of “meaning” versus “reproducing” orientations toward learning.  This study definitely found that DHH students were just as capable, if not more likely, to apply the meaning orientation to their learning and studying.  The researchers believe that this does not have to do with the context of their studies, but because of the difference in their Deaf education that may have pushed them to make those real-world applications while learning to give curriculum context.   However, the study also found that DHH students scored higher than hearing students on scores of reproducing orientations too.  In general, they found that DHH students felt more anxiety about succeeding in academics than hearing students do.  They believe that this anxiety and fear of failure may be tied to the idea that DHH students have a harder time making connections between topics.  This seems to have some implications on cognitive patterns and development of DHH students.
I wonder how much of these cognitive developments or attitudes are affected by their immersion in the Deaf community, or if these are simply the hallmarks of growing up DHH.  Regardless, it seems that Lindsay will feel anxious about succeeding academically, especially since she will need to rely on indirect knowledge transmission (text and interpreters), she will push herself to accurately and truly learn the information, and hopefully do well academically at the institution.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

In the Mainstream

The article I found, compared deaf and hard of hearing students in mainstream classes (or classes with hearing students) and separate classes (classes with only deaf and hard of hearing students).  The article found pros for both scenarios.  In the end, in both environments, the students were motivated by assessment and fear of failure, as well as good teaching and genuine acquisition of skills.  Students in the mainstream courses felt positively about developing and utilizing analytic skills (rather than rote memorization) and feeling that their instructors’ took personal interest in them and their success, including flexibility in methods of assessment.  However, classes from separate classes felt more positively about workload expectations, instructor feedback and communication, and the amount of choices offered in coursework.
The article begins by affirming that deaf and hard of hearing (or DHH) students are attending mainstream hearing institutions more and more.  The literature review was very informational to me as well.  It discussed how the previous studies included all kinds of deaf and hard of hearing, including those that were dependent on spoken English, dependent on ASL, and those that code switched between the two.   They found that in academic settings DHH students tended to absorb less content information than their hearing peers and that instruction in ASL and text does not necessarily create significantly better outcomes (but if there are positives differences, it is through text, not ASL), which is not really what my Chronicle article indicated (haha).  It also indicated that teachers who were skilled or experienced with teaching DHH students were better at motivating DHH students to utilize their resources and strengths.  DHH students that attend mainstream institutions also tend to retain more residual hearing (which is really interesting and definitely applicable to Lindsay’s experience).  Previous studies also emphasized the importance of having an interpreter and the frustration felt trying to communicate with the instructor.  How DHH students interpret their communication ability in the classroom seemed to predict grades at the end of the semester as well.  DHH students are also more likely make deep connections with their education than their hearing students.
This study explained some of their findings, such as why DHH students in mainstream classes are more sensitive to pace of teaching because they are often dependent on indirect methods (interpreters or text-captioning) and reluctant to ask questions in class because of the communication barrier.  The study also found that instructors of mainstream classes preferred instructor centered “information-transmission” teaching styles, while those in separate classes focused on “conceptual change”.  This may be part of why those in separate classes appeared to learn more, but the relationship between instruction style and success needs more studying.

Sunday, February 6, 2011

Debate over Deaf Education

This article discussed the history of how deaf children have been educated in predominantly hearing schools in the past, how they are taught now, and the method they are currently considering as most efficient, effective, and educational.  There are two ways that mainstream hearing schools have historically taught deaf children, oral or bilingual.  The oral method is when a teacher teaches with speech and visual cues.  Bilingual incorporates teaching with sign language as well.  People find that the sign language improves the actual amount of knowledge impressed upon children; however, it does not let them to truly develop their reading and writing skills.  There has been much research that shows that bilingual is more effective.  However, with increases in technology, deafness and other hearing impairments can be discovered even earlier than before.  This allows parents to invest in cochlear implants much earlier.  With the advent of cochlear implants, there seems to be an upswing back toward a more oral tradition of education.
This article is interesting in the sense that it does not address at all the turmoil that the Deaf community must feel.  The Deaf community tends to be particularly opposed to cochlear implants, as they believe it is robbing born-deaf children the special experience of being Deaf.  However, as technology improves, I can imagine that hearing parents are increasingly getting cochlear implants for their children.
I imagine that Lindsay has gone to school at an institution that is predominantly hearing.  I believe that she was taught bilingually.  She had a tutor that assisted with interpretation and any subjects that she struggled with.  It was not easy, but I believe she was fortunate enough to get a good education in order to attend a university, nevermind a predominantly hearing institution.  It must be quite difficult for Lindsay to transition into college where these interpreting services are not as readily available.  It must also be difficult with such a large campus, where many everyday things are not designed universally.  It only adds to the overwhelming sensation.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

Disability Services


I looked up the Disability Services offered at Bowling Green and Ohio State for deaf and hard of hearing students (at http://www.bgsu.edu/offices/sa/disability/page18309.html and http://ods.osu.edu/services/).  Compared to Bowling Green State University’s website, there are more resources directly available to prospective students perusing the website.  The website offers tips on how to transition to college, such as contacting the Office of Disability Services directly and immediately.  It also details the types of classes that will best prepare a student for the types of classes that are offered at Ohio State.  It also provides very detailed instructions on how to apply and register with the ODS.  They also offer a College Day specifically for high school students, families, and counselors to attend to really provide a specialized orientation and advice for these students.  Though only one day, this special session just for these students really send the nonverbal message that these students are valued at the institution.
Both Bowling Green and Ohio State offer scholarships for students with disabilities.  They both also provide voter registration services so that students won’t need to maneuver outside of campus without resources.  BGSU will lend out FM amplification systems for academic purposes.  They also provide Typewell Meaning-for-Meaning Translation, where a trained Typewell captionist uses two laptop computers provided by the DS Office to transmit a meaning-for-meaning translation of the content of classes and campus events. This information is simultaneously read by the attending student.  They also provide Computer Assisted Real-Time Captioning (CART) - also referred to as real time captioning (the instant translation of the spoken word into English text using a stenotype machine, notebook computer, and realtime software). The text is displayed on the computer screen, which is located in front of the student.  They also offer interpreting services up to 3 days in advance.  Ohio State also offers these services.  They request that you request interpretation as soon as possible. They cannot guarantee interpreting services less than seven days in advance.  When I first read Bowling Green’s deadline of three days, I remembered thinking that it was asking students to know way in advance, which makes Ohio State’s much more daunting.  At the same time though, this makes sense because Ohio State is so much larger than Bowling Green.  However, this really forces students to plan ahead and know what kind of programs and events they would want to attend, way in advance.  This puts a lot of pressure on these students, and could exclude them from joining in impromptu social activities, or joining friends on a floor to an event or program.  On the flip side, the webpage also offers ASL events both on and off-campus, including events sponsored by the ASL Club, Deaf churches, and other organizations including Deaf Women of Ohio, which is an organization that Lindsay may legitimately want to be a part of that is still in the Columbus area (http://www.deafwomenofohio.com/main_page.html).

Monday, January 24, 2011

Deaf Culture


I think something extremely crucial to this process is determining if she is deaf or Deaf.  There is definitely a difference.  I spoke with my friend Kayla from Columbus (the one who is working on ASL certification) about the differences between the “d” and the “D”.  Members of this big-D Deaf community do not view being deaf as a disability, but as a difference in human experience.  It can include family members of those who are deaf and hard of hearing and interpreters that identify with the culture, but does not automatically include all who are deaf and/ or hard of hearing.
Before the 19th century, deaf individuals lived very solitary lives among predominantly hearing people.  After this, Deaf culture was mainly established in Deaf schools and other social clubs.  Joining the Deaf community can happen at any time in one’s life depending on when one loses the ability to hear, the presence of a community where he or she resides, etc.  As mentioned in the first article, deafness is not really genetic.  While 50% of all deafness is caused by genetics, only 5% of all deaf people have deaf parents, which makes this an atypical social identity.
It’s also unique in the sense that there isn’t just one Deaf culture, but varied groups all around the world, even regionally.  Some typical values of the Deaf culture include a positive connotation with being d/Deaf, a distaste for Cochlear Implants (as it acknowledges deafness as a disability), using sign language as the main form of communication, as well as being more collectivistic (within the Deaf culture) as opposed to individualistic, like the rest of American culture.  There are some behavioral norms as well.  Certain conversation etiquette, such as, you should never walk in between a signed conversation (which makes sense, it’s the same as interrupting).  It is important to be as detailed as possible when describing environments or timing.  Arriving early is standard in Deaf culture.  When meeting someone new, a person of the Deaf community always seeks to find something in common with the other person, in a desire for to find connection.  As most communities are small, they seek to find common ground.
 I’ve decided to name my voice Lindsay.  I’m still not entirely sure how involved I really want her to be with the Deaf community, since she has a predominantly hearing family.  Though family members can be indoctrinated into the Deaf community, Kayla expressed that many in the Deaf community are still wary of all hearing people trying to get involved with the Deaf culture (including interpreters), so I imagine that it might have been very difficult for the family to try to become part of the Deaf culture, which might cause Lindsey to feel disjoint with truly identifying with the community.  I think that Lindsay was born hearing and lost her hearing ability at an early age because of a high fever, which explains why she can speak a bit.  She is mostly deaf with an extremely weak sense of hearing.